Monday 14 August 2023

Thoughts on Manga-Only Dazai [Bungo Stray Dogs]

(ex-posted from my tumblr)

Dumping more BSD-related thoughts onto here because I can’t get them out of my head. This time it’s purely about Dazai and how I personally think it’s really interesting how people view Dazai as a character in the general “Bungo Stray Dogs” universe and how he actually is portrayed as a character within the manga itself. This is all just word vomit btw and some free-flow thinking so sorry in advance if it doesn’t make sense and seems disjointed.

Dazai is an interesting character to me in the sense that… a large part of why I like him definitely comes from how Miyano Mamoru voiced him in the anime, and also because of all the backstory we get of him from the anime. So imagine my shock and confusion when I decided to read the manga (after S4) and realized none of that backstory is actually IN the manga. It actually made me pause and re-think a lot of Dazai’s character, as he is, in the manga, and whether I would have liked him as much without the extra info we get. I genuinely don’t think I would have. I’d certainly be curious about him, but I don’t think i would’ve necessarily liked him as much just as an individual character.

A manga-only reader actually know so little about Dazai. He really is just the mentor figure who appears to somehow know everything and shows up to drive the plot/motivate Atsushi, while also clearly hiding a million and one secrets in his trench coat. And manga-only readers do not get access those secrets.

Bungo Stray Dogs S5 Pacing Prediction

 (x-posted from my tumblr)

Okay. So, I have literally been sitting on this ALL DAY and decided I needed to make a post and shout this into the void to get out of my head. Also because I haven’t really seen anyone else float this idea before, and it’s either because my idea is clearly totally insane, or I’m a genius (lol jk, but seriously, I think it’s viable?)

First thing, this is basically my prediction of how the rest of the S5 eps are going to go and what manga chapters each ep will correlate with (and also how they might title the episodes):

EP1: The Strongest Man - ch78-80
EP2: The Answer to Everything - ch81-83
EP3: HERO VS CRIMINAL - ch84-87
EP4: HERO WAR, GANG WAR - ch88-91
EP5: Portway to the Sky P1 - ch92-94 (*currently*)
EP6: Portway to the Sky P2 - ch95-97
EP7: Portway to the Sky P3 - ch98-100
EP8: Wicked Realms Beyond Mankind - ch101-103
EP9: The Two Fuku’s - ch104
EP10: In the Small Room P1 - ch105-107
EP11: In the Small Room P2 - ch108-110

(chapters are based off how the chapters are counted in the tankobons, NOT the way the chapters are numbered when they are released monthly because Asagiri-sensei fucked up the numbering of the parts here and there with all the half chapters. Also if you count the pages - we’re going at about 100 pages of content per episode.)